The Effectiveness of Story Mapping and Comprehension Sterategies to Improve Reading Skills for Students with Reading Problems

Chitsaz, Fateme; Barzegar Bafroie, Kaazem; Zare, Maryam

doi:10.22054/jpe.2023.69792.2480

The Effectiveness of Story Mapping and Comprehension Sterategies to Improve Reading Skills for Students with Reading Problems

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

fateme chitsaz ¹

Kaazem Barzegar bafroie ²

Maryam zare ³

¹ Master of Educational Psychology, Yazd University, Yazd, Iran.

² Associate Professor, Department of Educational Sciences, Yazd University, Yazd, Iran.

³ Assistant Professor, Department of Educational Sciences, Yazd University, Yazd, Iran.

https://doi.org/10.22054/jpe.2023.69792.2480

Abstract

Abstract
The purpose of this study was to investigate whether teaching story mapping strategies and comprehension can improve the reading skills of students with reading difficulties. This study used a single subject experimental design with baseline, and the statistical population consisted of third-grade students with reading difficulties in Yazd during the 2020-2021 academic year. Due to the limitations imposed by the corona pandemic, only four male students were selected using convenience sampling, but one participant dropped out, leaving three participants who attended 12 sessions. The WISC-IV and NAMA tests were used to screen and establish baseline measures for the participants. Data were analyzed using percentage of recovery and index of stable change calculations. The research findings showed that six reading skills improved in the first and third participants, and eight skills improved in the second participant. All three participants showed significant growth in rhyming subtests, word comprehension, vowel removal, letter marks, and category marks. The first and second participants improved in reading non-words, while the second and third participants improved in comprehending text. These improvements were attributed to the teaching of story mapping strategies and comprehension. Overall, the results suggest that teaching story mapping strategies and comprehension can improve most reading skills in students with reading difficulties.
Extended Abstract

Introduction

Learning disorders are a common issue that children face, hindering their ability to learn and acquire crucial life skills (Rangebar et al., 2018). Reading is a vital skill that students should master at a young age as it increases their knowledge and enables them to continue their education later in life. Additionally, it strengthens social connections (Royanto, 2012). Students with reading problems often struggle with phonology, word decoding, fluency, and reading comprehension. This affects their education, learning, self-esteem, physical and mental health, and puts additional pressure on families and education officials, including teachers and school administrators. Therefore, therapeutic interventions are necessary in this field. The present study aims to investigate the effectiveness of teaching story mapping strategies and reading comprehension in improving the reading skills of students with reading problems.

Literature Review

The story mapping strategy is a method that directs individuals' attention to the relevant elements of a story through a specific structure. The outlines for a story map serve as a guide for important information in the narrative. These outlines serve to engage children with the story and provide them with context. The review is organized under these subheadings.
Overall, the research suggests that the story mapping strategy can be an effective tool for improving students' reading comprehension and engagement with the story. It can be particularly beneficial for students with learning or language difficulties, as well as those with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder. Additionally, the use of mobile software and survey techniques can further enhance the effectiveness of this strategy. By providing students with a clear structure for understanding and organizing the elements of a story, educators can help them develop stronger comprehension skills and become more confident readers.

Methodology

This study used a single subject experimental design with baseline, and the statistical population consisted of third-grade students with reading difficulties in Yazd during the 2020-2021 academic year. Due to the limitations imposed by the corona pandemic, only four male students were selected using convenience sampling, but one participant dropped out, leaving three participants who attended 12 sessions. The WISC-IV and NAMA tests were used to screen and establish baseline measures for the participants. Data were analyzed using percentage of recovery and index of stable change calculations.

Results

The research findings showed that six reading skills improved, in the first and third participants, and eight skills improved in the second participant. All three participants showed significant growth in rhyming subtests, word comprehension, vowel removal, letter marks, and category marks. The first and second participants improved in reading non-words, while the second and third participants improved in comprehending text. These improvements were attributed, to the teaching of story mapping strategies and comprehension. Overall, the results suggest that teaching story mapping strategies and comprehension can improve most reading skills in students with reading difficulties.

Conclusion

According to the findings, in order to answer the research question, in each participant (3 male students), out of ten reading skills that were measured by the Nama test, six skills have improved in the first and third participant, and eight skills have improved in the second subject. All three participants in the sub-tests of rhyme, word comprehension, and elimination of sounds, letter signs and category signs jointly achieved significant growth and change in these skills. In addition, in the first and second participants, reading non-words has become meaningful, and in the second and third participants, understanding the text has become meaningful; that these changes were caused by teaching story mapping strategies and reading comprehension. Teaching story mapping and reading comprehension strategies can be used as an effective educational program to improve the reading skills of students with reading problems.
Keywords: Comprehension Strategy, Reading Problems, Reading Skills, Story Mapping.

Keywords

Comprehension Strategy

Reading Problems

Reading Skills

Story Mapping

References

Alturki, N. (2017). The effectiveness of using group story-mapping strategy to improve reading comprehension of students with learning disabilities. Educational Research and Reviews, 12(18), 915-926. https://academicjournals.org/journal/ERR/article-abstract/1366E4866081

Asgharimoghadam, M. & Shaeiri, M. (2014). Clinically significant method of therapeutic changes: characteristics, calculation method, decision making and limitations. Clinical Psychology and Personality, 21(10), 191- 200. [In Persian] https://www.sid.ir/fa/journal/ ViewPaper.aspx?id=251898

Atadokht, A., Mohammadi, G., Taheri Fard, M., Sharbati, A. (2015). Comparison of the independent and context dependent cognitive styles and social problem solving in students with and without specific learning disorder. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 5(1), 86-100. [In Persian] http://jld.uma.ac.ir/article_365.html

Atadokht, A., Yagobi, V., Basharpoor, S., Zare, R. (2015). The diagnostic capability of the wechsler intelligence scale for children in quickly diagnosis of students with special learning disability. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 4(2), 55-69. [Persian] http://jld.uma.ac.ir/ article_261.html?lang=en

Berkeley, S. et al. (2011). Reading Comprehension Strategy Instruction and Attribution Retraining for Secondary Students With Learning and Other Mild Disabilities, Journal of Learning Disabilities, 44(1), 18–32. https://doi.org/10.1177/0022219410371677

Boulineau, T., et al. (2004). Use of Stoty Mapping to Increase the Story Gramar Text Comprehension of Elementary Students With Learning Disabilities, Learning Disability Quarterly, 27, 105- 121. https://doi.org/10.2307%2F1593645

Budiman, A. (2019). Improving students reading comprehension of narrative text through story mapping, Department, FKIP, Tanjungpura University, 1-8.

Elson, M & Hergenhan, B.C. (2009). Introduction to learning theories. Eighth edition, translated by Ali Seif (2019). Tehran: Doran Publishing. [In Persian]

Firmansyah, H & Sri Hidayati, I. (2019). Using Story Mapping Strategy and Reading Motivation to Improve Reading Narrative Comprehension Achievement of Tenth Graders of SMAN 1 Kotapadang, Journal of Linguistics and Language Teaching, 5(2), 44- 53. http://dx.doi.org/ 10.29300/ling.v5i2.2378

Gersten, R., et al. (2001). Teaching Reading Comprehension Strategies to Students with Learning Disabilities: A Review of Research, Review of Educational Research, 71(2), 279-320. http://dx.doi.org/10.3102/ 00346543071002279

Grigorenko, El., et al. (2020). Understanding, educating, and aupporting children with specific learning disabilities: 50 years of science and practice, American psychologist, 75(1), 37-51. Http://Dx.Doi.Org/10.1037/Amp0000452

Grünke, M. & Leidig. T. (2017). The Effects of an Intervention Combining Peer Tutoring with Story Mapping on the Text Comprehension of Struggling Readers: A Case Report. Educational Research Quarterly, 41 (1), 43-62. https://eric.ed.gov/?id=EJ1166637

Hallahan, D., et al. (2005). Learning Disabilities (Principles, Characteristics and Effective Teaching), translated by Hamid Alizadeh et al. (2013). Tehran: Arasbaran Publications. [In Persian]

hariri, P., Saberi, H., Abolmaali Alhosseini, K. (2016). The Effectiveness of a Combined Program of Direct Instruction and Phonological Awareness on Reading Fluency, Reading Comprehension, and Working Memory for First Grade Elementary School Students with Reading Problems. Psychology of Exceptional Individuals, 6(23), 51-81. [In Persian] https://dx.doi.org/10.22054/jpe.2016.7367

Harvey, M. (2013). Reading Comprehension: Strategies for Elementary and Secondary School Students, Reading Comprehension .https://www.lynchburg.edu/wp-content/uploads/volume-8-2013/HarveyM-Reading-Comprehension-Elementary-Secondary.pdf

Hedin, L. et al. (2011). Comprehension Strategy Instruction for Two Students with Attention-Related Disabilities, Preventing School Failure, 55(3), 148–157. https://doi.org/10.1080/1045988X.2010.499393

Jafarigohar, M., Karami, M. (2015). Promotion of High School EFL Learners’ Reading Comprehension Strategies through Dynamic Assessment. Technology of Education Journal (TEJ), 10(1), 11-24. [In Persian] https://dx.doi.org/10.22061/tej.2015.435

Jameel, A. (2022). The Effects of Story Mapping and Hortatory Exposition Techniques on Students’ Compositions, Education Research International, 1-11. https://doi.org/10.1155/2022/4300692

Kemp, S. (2017). A Reading Comprehension Strategy for Students with Learning Disabilities and Concomitant Speech-Language Impairments or ADHD. Journal of Education and Training, 4, 58-72. https://doi.org/10.5296/jet.v4i2.11614

Khoshhal, H. Hossein Khanzadeh, A., Parand A. (2015) Efficacy of Reading Comprehension Strategy Training on Reading Achievement among Students with Dyslexia. J Child Ment Health, 2 (1), 21-34. [In Persian] http://childmentalhealth.ir/article-1-36-fa.html

Kormi Nouri, R., & Moradi, A. (2005). Reading and dyslexia test (view), Tehran: University Jihad Publications. [In Persian]

Liao, H. C., & Wang, Y. h. (2018). Using comprehension strategies for students’ self-efficacy, anxiety, and proficiency in reading English as a foreign language. Social Behavior and Personality: An international journal, 46(3), 447- 458. https://doi.org/10.1177%2F2158244019861454

Mahdavi, J. & Tensfeldt, L. (2013). Untangling Reading Comprehension Strategy Instruction: Assisting Struggling Readers in the Primary Grades, Preventing School Failure, Alternative Education for Children and Youth, 57(2), 77-92. http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/1045988X.2012.668576

Mayes, S. D and Calhoun, S. L. (2006). Frequency of reading, math, and writing disabilities in children with clinical disorders, learning and Individual Differences, 16(2), 145-157. https://doi.org/10.1016/ j.lindif.2005.07.004

Moinalghorabaie, F., Islam, M., Fadaee, M. (2015). Prevalence of learning disabilities among primary school students in north khorasan province. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 5(1), 101-124. [In Persian] http://jld.uma.ac.ir/article_366.html

Moradi, A. & et al. (2016). Reliability and Validity of Reading and Dyslexia Test (NAMA). Advances in Cognitive Sciences, 18 (1), 22-34. [In Persian] http://icssjournal.ir/article-1-409-fa.html

Mousavi Moghadam, S., Bairami, M., bakhshipour, A., HamidPour, H. (2017). The Efficacy of Metacognitive Therapy on Reduction of Pathological Symptoms and Trait Anxiety Intensity in Patients with Generalized Anxiety Disorder. Clinical Psychology Studies, 7(27), 23-45. [In Persian] https://dx.doi.org/10.22054/jcps.2017.7906

Nosrati, F., Ghobari Bonab, B., Sharifi, S. (2021). The Effect of Online Teaching of a Combined Educational Model (direct and phonological awareness) on Improving the Fluent Reading of Students with Reading Learning, Psychology of Exceptional Individuals, 11(44), 57-83. [In Persian] https://dx.doi.org/10.22054/jpe.2022.59450.2295

Ozbek, A., Ergul, C. (2021.) Effectiveness of Comprehension Strategies Mobile App (COSMA) on Reading Comprehension Performances of Students with Learning Disabilities. Journal of Special Education Technology. https://doi.org/10.1177%2F01626434211013540

Paraz, M., Nourozivand, H. & Shafiei, S. (2021). Investigating the effect of transplant education on students' motivation. Studies and Research in Behavioral Sciences, 2 (5), 76-86. [In Persian] http://noo.rs/fyQeE

Ranjbar, M., et al. (2019). Comparing the Effectiveness of computerized cognitive rehabilitation and neuropsychological exercises on Improving working memory and continuous attention in students with dyslexia. Psychology of Exceptional Individuals, 9(34), 111-135. [In Persian] https://dx.doi.org/10.22054/jpe.2019.44751.2029

Royanto, L. R. (2012). The effect of an intervention program based on scaffolding to improve metacognitive strategies in reading: a study of year 3 elementary school students in Jakarta, Journal of Social and Behavioral Sciences, 69(10), 1601–1609. https://doi.org/10.1016 /j.sbspro.2012.12.105

Sadeghi, A., Rabiee, M., & Abedi, M. (2011). Validation and validation of the fourth edition of the Wechsler Children's Intelligence Scale. Developmental Psychology (Iranian Psychologists), 7(28), 377-386. [In Persian] https://www.sid.ir/fa/journal/ViewPaper.aspx?id=148869

Sari, T. et al. (2020). Investigating the Effect of Story Mapping Strategy toward Students’ Reading Comprehension of Narrative Text, Advances in Social Science, Education and Humanities Research, 411, 302-306. http://dx.doi.org/10.2991/assehr.k.200306.051

Seif, A. (2021). Modern Educational Psychology: The Psychology of Learning and Teaching. Tehran: Doran Publications. [In Persian]

Sharifi, A., Davari, R. (2012). Prevalence of learning disabilities in first and second grade students of elementary school in Chaharmahal Va bakhtiari Province. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 1(2), 63-76. [In Persian] http://jld.uma.ac.ir/article_97.html?lang=en

Sholichah, N. (2017). The Effect of Story Mapping on Reading Comprehension, INTAJ Jurnal Penelitian Ilmiah, 1, 29-48. https://doi.org/10.35897/intaj.v1i1.43

Sotozaki H. & Parlow H. (2006). Interhemispheric communication involving multiple tasks: a study of children with dyslexia. Brain and Language, 98, 89-101. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bandl.2006.04.001

Splittstoesser. J. (2020). The Effectiveness of Story Maps on Reading Comprehension, Master of Arts in Education, Education department, Curriculum and Instruction, Catherine University. https://sophia.stkate.edu/maed/371/

Sriyana, I. & Eusabinus, B. (2018). Using story mapping technique to improve students participation in reading comperhension of narrative text, Tanjungpura University, 1- 10. https://jurnal.untan.ac.id/index.php/jpdpb/article/view/30216

Swanson, P. N., & De La Paz, S. (1998). Teaching Effective Comprehension Strategies to Students with Learning and Reading Disabilities. Intervention in School and Clinic, 33(4), 209–218. https://doi.org/10.1177/105345129803300403

Taroyan, N. A., et al. (2007). Behavioral and neurophysiologi calcorrelcorre-lates of dyslexia in the continuous performance task, Clinical Neurophy siol- ogy, 118(4), 845-855. https://doi.org/10.1016/ j.clinph.2006.11.273

U.S. Department of Education. (2010). Twenty-first annual report to Congress on the implementation of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office.

Usman, S., Safitri, A., & Marhum, M. (2020). The Application of Story Mapping Technique to Improve Writing Skills. https://doi.org/10.2991/assehr.k.200323.059

Veisi, S., Imani, S., & Abu Ishaqi, M. (2019). The Effectiveness of Teaching Scotch-Teaching Methods on Cognitive Abilities of Students with Specific Learning Disabilities: A Test of the Concept of Vygotsky Approximate Growth Zone. Journal of New Strategies in Psychology and Educational Sciences, 1, 1-22. [In Persian] www.magiran.com/p2012836

Wallace, A. J. (2005). Early Identification of Learning Disorders Helps Children Succeed, Pediatric Annals, 34(4), 328-329. https://doi.org/10.3928/0090-4481-20050401-14

Woods, A. D., et al. (2020). How Stable Is Early Academic Performance? Using Cluster Analysis to Classify Low Achievement and EF. Learn Disabil, 53(1), 19- 35. https://doi.org/10.1177%2F0022219419881632

Wulandari, Novia. (2019). Implementation of Story Mapping and Mind Mapping Toward Students’ Reading Comprehension Enhancement: A Comparative Study, Journal of English Language Pedagogy, Literature and Culture, 4(1), 23-32. https://doi.org/10.35974/acuity.v4i1.678

Yarimoghadam, N., Delavar, A., Dortaj, F., Hagalizadeh, K. (2020). Investigating the effect of negative emotions (anxiety and depression) on reading comprehension and problem solving in order to develop a structural model in the elementary period of Hamedan. Journal of Educational Psychology Studies, 17(37), 230-199. [In Persian] https://dx.doi.org/10.22111/jeps.2019.5004