Enriching the Philosophy for Children Program with Digital Technologies and Examining its Effect on Rumination and Interpersonal Relationships

Yavari, Fatemeh; Sajadipoor, Farideh

doi:10.22054/jpe.2023.72908.2560

Enriching the Philosophy for Children Program with Digital Technologies and Examining its Effect on Rumination and Interpersonal Relationships

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

fatemeh yavari

farideh sajadipoor

Lecturer, Department of Educational Sciences and Psychology, Payam Noor University of Razvanshahr, Yazd, Iran.

https://doi.org/10.22054/jpe.2023.72908.2560

Abstract

Abstract
The present study was conducted investigating the psychometric properties of the Behavioral Rating Inventory of Executive Functions - Second Edition (BRIEF-2) in students with externalizing behavior problems. The method was based on correlation research. The statistical population consisted of all male students with behavioral problems between the ages 7 and 12 in East Azarbayejan province who were studying in the academic year 2021-2022. To select the sample, first, students with externalizing behavior problems were identified. Then their parents completed the parent form of Behavioral Rating Inventory of Executive Functions - Second Edition (BRIEF-2) and Coolidge's Neuropsychological Questionnaire (2002). The data was analyzed with 599 people. Cronbach's alpha coefficient, confirmatory factor analysis, and criterion validity were used to analyze the data. The results showed that the behavioral rating inventory of executive functions - second edition (BRIEF-2) has good reliability and validity. Therefore, this scale can be used to evaluate executive functions in students with externalizing behavior problems.
Keywords: psychometric properties, behavior rating inventory of executive function, externalizing behavioral problems.

Extended Abstract

Introduction

Externalizing problems such as disruptive behavior, aggression, and breaking rules can be a significant public health issue. These symptoms can have serious consequences for individuals, including dealing with disruptive behavior, feeling insecure or victimized, and incurring economic costs for prevention, treatment, and trials (Constanty et al., 2021). When evaluating children with externalizing behavior problems, it's important to assess their executive functions. Executive functions refer to the cognitive processes that are involved in regulating behavior, such as attention, working memory, and self-control. There is a relationship between executive functions and externalizing behavior problems, which means that how well a child can regulate their behavior is linked to their cognitive abilities. By assessing executive functions, we can better understand the cognitive and behavioral factors that contribute to externalizing behavior problems in children. The Behavior Rating Inventory of Executive Function, Second Edition (BRIEF-2) is currently the most widely used tool for measuring executive functions in children (Pino Muñoz et al., 2021; Parhoon et al., 2022). While BRIEF-2 is a comprehensive tool for assessing executive functions in children, its psychometric features have not been fully examined in children with externalizing behavior problems. The current research aims to answer the question of whether the psychometric characteristics of the BRIEF-2 parent form are appropriate for use in assessing executive functions in students with externalizing behavior problems.
Research Question
Are the psychometric characteristics of the BRIEF-2 parent form suitable for assessing executive functions in students with externalizing behavior problems?

Literature Review

Anastasiadis (2023) conducted a study to examine the clinical usefulness of the BRIEF-2 and its associated scales in differentiating between pediatric ADHD presentations and comorbidity. The study used archival data from 211 children between the ages of 5 and 12 who were seen at a university-based ADHD Evaluation Clinic. Ratings from parents and teachers were analyzed separately. The results of the study were consistent with predictions, showing that the Emotional Regulation Index (ERI) was highest in the combined presentation of ADHD. Parhoon et al., (2021) conducted a study to examine the psychometric properties of the Persian version of BRIEF-2 parent-form in children between the ages of six and 12 years. The study used confirmatory factor analysis to analyze the internal structure of the BRIEF-2. The results showed that the model with three indexes (Behavioral, Emotional, and Cognitive) and nine scales (Inhibit, Shift, Self-Monitor, Emotional Control, Initiate, Working Memory, Plan/Organize, Organization of Materials, and Task-Monitor) had a good fit. Jiménez & Lucas-Molina (2019) conducted a study to examine two aspects of BRIEF-2 in a sample of primary school-aged children. The results of the study showed that the confirmatory factor analysis of BRIEF-2 revealed a good fit for the sample. The model with three indexes (Behavioral, Emotional, and Cognitive) and nine scales (Inhibit, Shift, Self-Monitor, Emotional Control, Initiate, Working Memory, Plan/Organize, Organization of Materials, and Task-Monitor) was found to be an appropriate fit for the data.

Methodology

The current research used a descriptive correlational-normative study method. The statistical population for this study included all male students between the ages of 7 and 12 years old who had behavioral problems and were studying in East Azarbaijan province during the academic year of 2021-2022. The final analysis of the current research included data from 599 questionnaires. The researchers used three different tools to collect data: The Child Behavior Checklist (CBCL), the Behavioral Rating Scale of Executive Functions - Second Edition (BRIEF-2), and the Coolidge Neuropsychological Questionnaire. The researchers used two different software programs, SPSS and Lisrel, to examine the psychometric properties of the BRIEF-2.

Results

The results of the confirmatory factor analysis of BRIEF-2 in Table 1 and Figure 2 showed that all fit indices, including the square root of the mean error of approximation (RMSEA), were within the desired range. This indicates that the model used in the questionnaire data is an appropriate fit for the data.
Table 1. All fit indices of BRIEF-2 confirmatory factor analysis.

Fitness indices

Values

RMSEA

0.098

NFI

0.96

NNFI

0.95

CFI

0.97

GFI

0.94

AGFI

0.89

Fig. 1. Estimation of standardized coefficients

Discussion

The results of the study showed that the BRIEF-2 has good reliability, as indicated by the examination of Cronbach's alpha coefficients and internal consistency. Additionally, the confirmatory factor analysis confirmed the three-factor model of the scale and its nine components. This suggests that the three-factor structure of the BRIEF-2 is desirable and acceptable in the studied population of school-aged children with externalizing behavioral problems. This finding is in line with the research results of Parhoon et al. (2022), Parhoon et al. (2021), Anastasiadis (2023) and Jiménez & Lucas-Molina (2019).
One limitation of this study is that the statistical population was limited to primary school-aged male students with externalizing behavioral problems. Therefore, caution should be taken when generalizing the results to other groups of children. Additionally, the data used in this study was limited to participants from East Azarbaijan province. This means that the results may not be representative of other regions or populations. Besides all limitations, it is suggested that the BRIEF-2 be used as an evaluation and diagnostic tool for assessing executive functions in primary school-aged students with externalizing behavior problems.

Conclusion

The results of this study suggest that children with high levels of behavioral problems may experience more difficulties with executive functions, which can negatively impact their emotional and motivational abilities. Based on the desirable psychometric properties of the BRIEF-2 and its appropriate criterion validity, it can be used as a tool to evaluate the executive functions of primary school-aged students with externalizing behavior problems.
Acknowledgments
The researchers express their sincere gratitude and appreciation to all the participants who contributed to the implementation of this research. Without their participation, this study would not have been possible.

Keywords

philosophy for children

rumination

interpersonal relationships

digital technologies.

Adalat, Ali and Makundi, Behrouz. (2019). The effectiveness of positive thinking training on stress, rumination and body image concerns in mastectomized women. Iranian Journal of Rehabilitation Research, 6(1), 69-76.

Andalib, Sima, Abedi, Mohammad Reza, Neshat Dost, Hamid Taher and Aghaei, Asghar. (2019). Comparison of the effectiveness of experimental treatment package with compassion and happiness-based therapy and rumination in depressed patients. Journal of Clinical Psychology. 12th ed. no. 1. 25 consecutive.

Ann Maro, Carol. (2017). Forgiveness - Peace to your little heart, translated by Barzo Serizadi. (2017). Tehran: Sabrin Publications

Bagherinejad, Mina, Salehi Faderdi, Javad and Tabatabai, Seyyed Mahmoud. (2009). The relationship between rumination and depression in a sample of Iranian students. Volume 11. Number 1. Pages 21 to 38

Bernie Fee, Oscar. (2010). what do I mean Translated by Arzoo Nir Ahmadi (2010). Tehran: Shahrtash Publishing House.

Fathi, Leila, Qudsi, Akhr and Naderi, Ezzatullah (2015). The effects of teaching philosophy to children through collaborative research on students' interpersonal relationships. Education Quarterly. No. 140.

Girard, Sylvie. (2016). For your health, translated by Zohra Natghi (2016). Tehran: Raz Baran Publications.

Habibi, Ramin, Farid, Abolfazl, Masrabadi, Javad and Bahadri, Jafar. (2018). The effectiveness of teaching social and emotional skills to improve students' interpersonal relationships. Journal of Education Strategies in Medical Sciences. Period 12. no. 1.

Habner, Dawn. (2012). What should I do if I keep complaining, translated by Hossein Masnan Farsi (2012). Tehran: Kam Publications.

Hassanzadeh, Farhad. (2013). P, T, Ko..., Tehran: Publications of the Center for Intellectual Development of Children and Adolescents.

Hedayati, Mahbubeh, and Qaidi, Yahya. (2010). The effect of children's philosophy program through the research community method on improving interpersonal relationship skills of elementary school students. Childhood and Philosophy, 5(9), 199-217.

Heydari, Iraj, Seifi, Mohammad and Moradi Mkhles, Hossein (2018). Developing critical thinking skills in the context of multimedia learning environments based on the constructivist approach. Ethical Research, 9th ed. No. 4.

Ismailizadeh, Timour and Karami, Ismail (2014). Introducing multimedia philosophy for children (p4c) and investigating its effects on primary school students' interaction. Andisheh and Child Quarterly, second year, series 1, number 21.

Ismailzadeh, Timour H., Allah Karami, Azad and Mousavi, Frank. (2015). The effectiveness of multimedia philosophy for children on sixth grade elementary students' problem solving. Educational Technology Quarterly. Volume 12. Number 4.

Jamshidi, Ali. (2001). Comparative study of social communication skills of students with special learning disabilities and normal children aged 8-12 years in Tehran. Earned a master's degree in psychology of exceptional children in the academic year 80-81. Allameh Tabatabaei University.

Jangi Zahi, Hamidreza, Zarei Zawarki, Ismail, Nili Ahmedabadi, Mohammadreza, und Delavar, Ali. (2017). Designing and validating a multimedia educational model for mentally retarded students, Journal of Exceptional Children, 17th year, No. 1 (63), 31-52.

Kabiri, Ali Akbar and Vahedi, Mehdi (2020). The effectiveness of philosophy for garden children digital technologies on cognitive biases and perceptions of competence of homeless and maltreated boys. Journal of Psychological Sciences, 110.

Kabiri, Ali Akbar, Ghasemi, Ali, Zarei Zawarki, Ismail and Rivandi, Rehane (2018). The effect of implementing philosophy program for children using technology on academic optimism and progress motivation of second grade male students in Hamadan City. Quarterly journal of cognitive strategies in learning. Eighth volume number fifteen.

Kashani Vahid, Leila, Afrooz, Gholam Ali, Shekohi Yekta, Mohsen, Kharazi, Kamal and Ghobari Bonab, Baqir (2014). Designing and compiling an educational program for interpersonal problem solving with a creative approach and investigating its effectiveness in improving gifted students' social skills. Two quarterly journals of social cognition. Fifth year Number 2.

Kazemi, Nawab, Arjamandnia, Ali Akbar, Moradi, Reihaneh, Mohammadi, Seyed Taghi and Sadeghi Fard, Maryam (2019). The effectiveness of self-compassion training on psychological well-being and rumination in mothers of students with specific learning disabilities. The Emergence of Psychology. Vol. 9. No. 1. 46 consecutive.

LH, Lewis. (2008). I am what I think, translated by Maryam Razaghi (2010). Tehran: Avash Publications.

Martin, Seligman. (2015). The optimistic child, translated by Forozandeh Davrpanah (2016). Tehran: Rushd Publishing House.

Mohammadzadeh, Zahra (2014). The impact of educational technology on children's thinking and common philosophical views about it. The fourth national conference on sustainable development and educational science and psychology. Social and cultural studies.

Moradi Qaim Maqam, Hojjatullah and Jola, Razia (2016). Guide to teaching life skills (problem solving, decision making and creative thinking), first edition, Tehran: Shelak Publications.

Moradi, Rahim. Zarei Zawarki, Ismail, Sharifi Daramadi, Parviz, Nili Ahmedabadi, Mohammadreza and Delavar, Ali. (2019). Enriching the English language curriculum with an assistive technology approach and investigating its impact on the learning of students with physical and motor disabilities: New guidelines for inclusive education, Journal of Educational Strategies in Medical Sciences, 12(1).

Naqd Ali, Mohsen and Panahi, Zahra. (2018). The relationship of research community in philosophy program for children with active and collaborative teaching methods. Thought and Child Quarterly. 2nd ed. No. 2, pp. 101-126

Rezaei, Nur Mohammad, Pedrvand, Hafez, Abdul Rezaei, Nader and Rezaei, Ali Mohammad. (2013). Investigating the effects of implementing the philosophy program for children on increasing creativity and fluid components, flexibility, initiative and expansion, Journal of Innovation and Creativity in Human Sciences. Period 4, Number 4.

Silverastan, Shel. (2012). The Giving Tree, translated by Razi Hirmandi. (2012). Tehran: Arvin Publications.

The man, Paul Fleisch. (2008). Half-way Inn, translated by Vakili Publications (2009). Tehran: Publications of the Center for Intellectual Development of Children and Adolescents.

Zabih Elah, Elahi, Zarei Zwarki, Ismail, Sharifi Daramdi, Parviz, Nowrozi, Dariush und Delavar, Ali. (2016). "Design and Validation of an Educational Model of Using Mobile Phones for Visually Impaired Students, New Approaches in Teaching and Learning Quarterly, Journal of Curriculum Technology, 1 (2), 71-86.

Zarei Zwarki, Esmail. (2015). Curriculum design for master's program in educational technology with emphasis on exceptional education in Iran. Quarterly research in educational systems. Issue 39.